The Honest Truth About Dishonesty by Dan Ariely, book cover
Psychology

The Honest Truth About Dishonesty summary

How We Lie to Everyone, Especially Ourselves

The book in one sentence

Most cheating comes from regular people who bend the rules just enough to profit while still believing they are honest.

Overview

Most of us think cheaters are a few bad apples doing cold math on the odds of getting caught. Dan Ariely ran years of clever experiments and found the opposite. Almost everyone cheats a little, and it has less to do with the fear of punishment than with the story we tell ourselves.

Key idea 1: Almost Everyone Cheats a Little

Economists have a tidy story about why people break rules. Gary Becker called it the rational model of crime. You weigh what you stand to gain against the odds of getting caught and the size of the punishment. If the math works out in your favor, you cheat. Ariely put this idea to the test with a simple puzzle. People got a sheet of twenty math problems, each a grid of numbers, and had five minutes to find the two numbers in each grid that add up to ten. They earned a small amount of money for every one they solved. One group handed their sheet to the experimenter, so no cheating was possible, and they solved about four on average. Another group got to shred their own sheet and simply report how many they got right. With no way to get caught, that group reported about six. So people cheated, but only by a couple of problems. Here is the strange part. If the rational model were true, people who could shred the evidence would claim all twenty, since the reward was guaranteed and the risk was zero. Almost nobody did. And when Ariely raised the payment per answer, or lowered the odds of being watched, the amount of cheating barely moved. A bigger prize did not tempt people into bigger lies. That breaks the tidy story. The real picture is a huge number of ordinary people, each fudging a little, and those small amounts add up to far more damage across a society than the rare big thief ever could. Think about it in your own life. Most people would never rob a bank, but plenty will round up an expense or claim a few more hours than they actually worked. Seeing the world clearly means you stop looking for a handful of villains and start expecting small, everyday cheating from mostly good people, yourself included.

7 more key ideas in the app

  1. 2. The Fudge Factor
  2. 3. A Reminder of Right and Wrong Shrinks Cheating
  3. 4. One Step From Cash, We Cheat More
  4. 5. Conflicts of Interest Bend Us Without Our Knowing
  5. 6. Tired People Cheat More
  6. 7. Wearing Fakes Makes Us Feel Like Fakes
  7. 8. Cheating Spreads Like a Cold
Read the full Dib in the app

Did you know?

  • Dan Ariely's path into studying human behavior began after a teenage accident left him with burns over much of his body, and the long recovery got him asking why people, including his own doctors, make the choices they do.
  • Ariely and his team ran the matrix cheating puzzle on tens of thousands of people, and the result barely changed: most fudged just a little, while almost no one claimed a perfect score.

Coming soon to the App Store and Google Play

DibsDabs for iPhone and Android is almost ready. Want to know the moment it's out? Send us a note and we'll tell you.

iPhone Coming soon Android Coming soon
Notify me at launch