Switch by Chip Heath and Dan Heath, book cover
Communication

Switch summary

How to Change Things When Change Is Hard

The book in one sentence

Most change is hard because our reasoning mind and our emotional side pull in different directions, so real change means guiding both of them while also clearing the path they travel.

Overview

Change feels hard, and we usually blame the wrong thing. Chip and Dan Heath argue that our thinking brain and our feeling brain want different things, and the ground between them is often a mess. Fix all three and stubborn problems start to move.

Key idea 1: Meet the Rider and the Elephant

To understand why change is hard, the Heaths borrow a picture from psychologist Jonathan Haidt. Imagine a person riding an elephant. The Rider is your planning, reasoning mind. He holds the reins and looks like he is in charge. But he is tiny next to the Elephant under him. The Elephant is your emotional side, the part that feels fear and craving. When the Rider and the Elephant disagree about which way to go, the six-ton Elephant almost always wins. That is why you can know you should save money or go to bed early and still do the opposite.

Each side has a real weakness. The Elephant looks for the quick payoff and hates anything that feels hard or slow. The Rider can plan, but he tends to spin in place, overthinking and hunting for the perfect answer instead of moving. There is a third piece too. The Path is the situation around both of them, the road they walk. Shape the Path well and the trip gets easier no matter how the Rider and Elephant feel.

The Heaths point to a study that shows how fragile the Rider is. Researchers sat hungry students in a room that smelled of fresh cookies. Some were allowed to eat the cookies. Others had to eat radishes instead and leave the cookies alone. Then everyone got a puzzle that was secretly impossible. The students who had resisted the cookies gave up after about eight minutes. The ones who ate freely kept at it for nineteen. Holding back had drained them. Self-control runs on a limited tank, and when it empties, we look lazy even though we are just worn out.

This reframes what we call resistance. When people do not change, we assume they are stubborn or do not care. Often the real story is quieter. The Rider has no clear direction, so he stalls. The Elephant has no motivation, so it will not move. Or the Path is full of obstacles that make the right thing hard. The rest of the book is built on these three levers. You direct the Rider so he knows where to go. You motivate the Elephant so it wants to go. And you shape the Path so the trip is smooth. Leave out any one of them and change tends to stall.

7 more key ideas in the app

  1. 2. Follow the Bright Spots
  2. 3. Script the Critical Moves
  3. 4. Find the Feeling
  4. 5. Shrink the Change
  5. 6. Grow Your People
  6. 7. Tweak the Environment
  7. 8. Rally the Herd
Read the full Dib in the app

Did you know?

  • Chip and Dan Heath are brothers who write books together while working at different schools, Chip at Stanford's business school and Dan at Duke. Their other titles include Made to Stick and The Power of Moments.
  • The Rider-and-Elephant image is not the Heaths' own invention. They borrowed it from psychologist Jonathan Haidt, who used it in his book The Happiness Hypothesis to describe the split between our reasoning and emotional sides.

Coming soon to the App Store and Google Play

DibsDabs for iPhone and Android is almost ready. Want to know the moment it's out? Send us a note and we'll tell you.

iPhone Coming soon Android Coming soon
Notify me at launch