Why We Get Fat by Gary Taubes, book cover
Health & Fitness

Why We Get Fat summary

And What to Do About It

The book in one sentence

We get fat not because we eat too much and move too little, but because carbohydrates, especially sugar and refined starch, spike the hormone insulin that locks fuel into our fat cells, so the cure is changing what we eat rather than counting calories.

Overview

Gary Taubes says the reason we get fat is not that we eat too much and move too little. The real driver is the food itself, mostly sugar and refined carbs, which spike a hormone that tells your body to store fat. Fix the diet, not your willpower.

Key idea 1: Eating Too Much Explains Nothing

The story we all grew up with is simple. We get fat because we take in more calories than we burn. Eat less, move more, and the fat comes off. Taubes says this idea is not wrong exactly, but it is useless. It is like saying a room got crowded because more people walked in than walked out. That is true, but it tells you nothing about why the crowd formed. The real question is what made people come in.

Here is the trap. When you say someone got fat by overeating, you are not naming a cause. You are just describing what fat people do. Of course they took in extra energy. That extra energy is the fat. Saying overeating caused the fat is like saying a room got hot because the temperature went up. You have restated the problem and called it an answer.

Taubes flips the logic with a question about growing teenagers. A teenage boy might eat a huge amount as he shoots up in height. Do we say he grew tall because he ate so much? No. We say he ate so much because he was growing. The growth came first and drove the hunger. Taubes argues fat can work the same way. Maybe your body is being pushed to store fat, and that storage is what makes you hungry and tired, so you eat more and move less.

This matters because it changes who is to blame. The calorie story quietly says fat people are gluttons and sloths with weak willpower. If that were true, why can two people eat the same meals and move the same amount, yet one stays lean and one does not?

To use this, stop treating your appetite as a character flaw. It is a signal. When your body wants to hoard fat, hunger and fatigue follow. The nuance is that calories still obey the laws of physics. Taubes is not denying that. He is saying calories in and calories out are the result of getting fat, not the cause.

7 more key ideas in the app

  1. 2. Fatness Follows Poverty, Not Feasting
  2. 3. Insulin Is the Fat Switch
  3. 4. Carbs Are What Drive the Fat
  4. 5. Exercise Will Not Make You Thin
  5. 6. Your Fat Has a Life of Its Own
  6. 7. How the Bad Advice Took Over
  7. 8. What To Actually Do About It
Read the full Dib in the app

Did you know?

  • Gary Taubes is a science journalist trained in physics and aerospace engineering, not a doctor or nutritionist.
  • This book is a shorter, plain-language version of his earlier and much larger work, Good Calories, Bad Calories.
  • Taubes has won the Science in Society Journalism Award from the National Association of Science Writers more than once.

Featured in: Eat Well, Live Long, Eat for health (guide)

Coming soon to the App Store and Google Play

DibsDabs for iPhone and Android is almost ready. Want to know the moment it's out? Send us a note and we'll tell you.

iPhone Coming soon Android Coming soon
Notify me at launch