
When Genius Failed summary
The Rise and Fall of Long-Term Capital Management
The book in one sentence
Even the smartest models and the biggest brains cannot tame markets, because too much borrowed money turns a rare shock into total ruin.
Overview
In 1994 a group of Wall Street traders and two Nobel Prize winners built a hedge fund that seemed unable to lose. Four years later it nearly took the whole financial system down with it. Roger Lowenstein tells how the smartest people in finance managed to blow up.
Key idea 1: Genius Was No Shield
When John Meriwether left Salomon Brothers, he was already a legend on Wall Street. He had run the bond arbitrage desk there and made the firm a fortune before a trading scandal pushed him out. In 1994 he started his own fund, Long-Term Capital Management, and set out to hire the sharpest minds in finance. He got them. Myron Scholes and Robert Merton joined, the two economists behind the famous formula for pricing options. In 1997 they would share a Nobel Prize. David Mullins came aboard too, straight from being vice chairman of the Federal Reserve. This was a faculty of geniuses running a trading floor.
Investors treated the fund like a sure thing. It opened with more than a billion dollars, a giant sum for a startup, and big banks lined up to lend it more and to copy its trades. Meriwether's pitch was simple in spirit. Markets have small, measurable flaws in their prices, and with enough brainpower and math you can find them and bet on them while keeping the risk under tight control. For a while it looked true. The fund returned around 40 percent a year in 1995 and 1996, even after fat fees. Money poured in.
The title of the book gives away the ending. These were not reckless gamblers or con men. They were the most credentialed team ever gathered in one place, and within four years the fund was a smoking crater that needed a rescue to keep from dragging major banks down with it. That is the part worth sitting with. Their failure grew straight out of too much faith in their own brains.
Lowenstein's warning is about how we treat brilliance. A wall of degrees and awards makes us assume the people behind them have risk figured out, so we stop asking hard questions. The traders assumed the same about themselves. When you see a team that looks too smart to fail, that is exactly the moment to ask what happens if they turn out to be wrong. The smartest people in the room had built something that could not survive being wrong even once.
7 more key ideas in the app
- 2. Picking Up Nickels
- 3. Borrowed Money Cuts Both Ways
- 4. When The Models Met The Real World
- 5. In A Panic, Everything Moves Together
- 6. Too Big To Sell
- 7. Winning Made Them Reckless
- 8. Too Connected To Fail
Did you know?
- Two of the fund's partners, Myron Scholes and Robert Merton, won the Nobel Prize in economics in 1997 for their work on pricing options. Less than a year later, the fund they helped run nearly took down the market.
- John Meriwether, the fund's founder, first became famous in Michael Lewis's book Liar's Poker, where he is said to have answered a boss's one million dollar bet by offering to play instead for ten million.
Your Money or Your Life
A Random Walk Down Wall Street
Antifragile
Beating the Street
Broke Millennial