Maybe You Should Talk to Someone by Lori Gottlieb, book cover
Psychology

Maybe You Should Talk to Someone summary

A Therapist, Her Therapist, and Our Lives Revealed

The book in one sentence

We stay stuck because we cling to the stories we tell about our lives, and we start to change only when we face our pain honestly and let another person truly see us.

Overview

Lori Gottlieb is a therapist who falls apart after a sudden breakup and lands in therapy herself. She weaves her own sessions with the stories of four patients, from a grieving TV writer to a young woman facing death. It shows how we stay stuck and what it takes to finally change.

Key idea 1: You Are an Unreliable Narrator

We all walk around with a story about our life. In the story, we know who the good guys are and why we turned out the way we did. Gottlieb says a big part of therapy is noticing that this story is not the whole truth. We drop the parts that make us look bad. We keep the parts that keep us safe. Take John, the TV writer who shows up calling everyone around him an idiot. His story is simple: he is surrounded by stupid people, and that is why he is miserable. It takes months before the real story leaks out. His young son Gabe died in a car accident, and his own mother died when he was six. The everyone is an idiot story is easier to carry than the grief underneath it. Gottlieb catches herself doing the same thing. After her boyfriend leaves, her story is that he is a heartless man who dumped a good woman for no reason. Her therapist Wendell keeps gently poking at the gaps until she starts to see the parts she skipped, like her own fears and the ways she dodged hard truths. You are not making things up on purpose. Memory works like a storyteller, bending events to fit what you already believe. When the story says this always happens to me or I am just broken, you stop looking for other explanations. You act out the same plot again and again because you cannot picture a different one. Gottlieb treats you like the author, not only the character. Authors can revise. You can ask what you left out and whether the meaning you gave an event is the only one available. To use this, write down the story you tell about a stuck part of your life. Then read it as if a friend wrote it, and look for the missing pieces. Notice the words always and never, because they are usually signs the story has hardened into a rule. You do not have to throw the whole thing out. You just have to stay open to a rewrite.

7 more key ideas in the app

  1. 2. The Cell Door Is Already Open
  2. 3. Every Change Is Also a Loss
  3. 4. You Cannot Numb One Feeling at a Time
  4. 5. Underneath It All Is the Fear of Dying
  5. 6. Real Help Sometimes Feels Like a Kick
  6. 7. There Is a Gap Between Feeling and Doing
  7. 8. We Are More Alike Than We Admit
Read the full Dib in the app

Did you know?

  • Gottlieb writes the weekly Dear Therapist advice column for The Atlantic, so she spends her days both practicing therapy and answering readers' problems in print.
  • Before she became a therapist, she worked in Hollywood, including on the medical drama ER, and she started medical school at Stanford before leaving to write.

Coming soon to the App Store and Google Play

DibsDabs for iPhone and Android is almost ready. Want to know the moment it's out? Send us a note and we'll tell you.

iPhone Coming soon Android Coming soon
Notify me at launch