Justice: What's the Right Thing to Do? by Michael J. Sandel, book cover
Philosophy

Justice: What's the Right Thing to Do? summary

What's the Right Thing to Do?

The book in one sentence

Debates about justice really turn on three rival ideas, welfare, freedom, and virtue, and a fair society cannot dodge hard questions about the good life by pretending to stay neutral.

Overview

A runaway trolley is about to kill five people. You can pull a lever to send it onto another track, where it will kill one. Do you pull it? Sandel uses puzzles like this to drag our gut reactions into the open and ask the oldest question there is: what is the right thing to do?

Key idea 1: Every Argument About Justice Hides Three Questions

Sandel opens by showing that debates about what is fair almost never stay simple. Behind them sit three big ideas about what justice is really about, and most of us mix them together without noticing. The first idea is welfare. On this view, the just choice is the one that makes people better off, that adds up to the most happiness or the most good. The second is freedom. Here justice means respecting each person's right to choose for themselves, without others forcing a plan onto them. The third is virtue. On this older view, a just society is one that honors good character and helps people live well, not one that stays neutral about how they should live. To make you feel the tension, Sandel uses the famous trolley problem. A runaway trolley will kill five workers on the track ahead. You can throw a switch and send it onto a side track where it kills only one. Most people say throw the switch, because five lives beat one. That is welfare thinking. But change the setup. Now you are on a bridge next to a large stranger, and the only way to stop the trolley is to push him onto the track. Same math, five saved for one lost, yet almost nobody is willing to push. Something feels deeply wrong about using a person as a mere tool, even for a good result. That flip is the whole point. Your gut just switched from counting lives to protecting a person's right not to be sacrificed. You did not change your math, you changed your moral theory, and you probably did not even notice. Here is how to use this. The next time you argue about a hard issue, taxes, healthcare, punishment, ask which of the three questions you are really answering. Are you talking about outcomes, about rights, or about what kind of people we should be? A common mistake is to think you disagree about the facts when you actually disagree about which value comes first. Naming the real question is the start of thinking clearly.

7 more key ideas in the app

  1. 2. The Greatest Happiness for the Greatest Number
  2. 3. Some Pleasures Are Higher Than Others
  3. 4. You Own Yourself, So Hands Off
  4. 5. Do the Right Thing for the Right Reason
  5. 6. Some Things Money Should Not Buy
  6. 7. Justice Means Giving People Their Due
  7. 8. You Cannot Be Just and Stay Neutral About the Good
Read the full Dib in the app

Did you know?

  • The book grew out of Sandel's Harvard course Justice, one of the most popular classes in the university's history, taken by over fifteen thousand students.
  • The course was filmed and released for free online and on public television, reaching a huge global audience.
  • Justice: What's the Right Thing to Do? was published in 2009 by Farrar, Straus and Giroux.

Coming soon to the App Store and Google Play

DibsDabs for iPhone and Android is almost ready. Want to know the moment it's out? Send us a note and we'll tell you.

iPhone Coming soon Android Coming soon
Notify me at launch