Good Calories, Bad Calories by Gary Taubes, book cover
Health & Fitness

Good Calories, Bad Calories summary

Challenging the Conventional Wisdom on Diet, Weight Control, and Disease

The book in one sentence

Refined carbohydrates and sugar, not dietary fat, are the main cause of obesity and the chronic diseases of modern life, because they raise insulin and drive the body to store fat.

Overview

For fifty years we were told that fat makes us fat and clogs our hearts. Gary Taubes digs through the science and finds the case was never really proven. His book points the finger somewhere else, at the sugar and white flour on nearly every plate.

Key idea 1: The Fear of Fat Was Never Proven

Start with the idea most of us grew up with. Eating fat raises your cholesterol, which clogs your arteries and gives you a heart attack. Taubes traces this belief back mostly to one man, a scientist named Ancel Keys. In the 1950s Keys pushed what he called the diet-heart hypothesis. One of his famous early charts lined up a handful of countries where more fat in the diet went with more heart disease. It looked like proof. But data existed for many more countries, around twenty-two of them, and when critics added the rest the neat line fell apart. Keys had kept the ones that fit and set aside the ones that did not, like France, where people eat plenty of fat and have healthy hearts.

Here is the part that matters. A pattern in a chart is not the same as cause. Two things can rise together for a reason that has nothing to do with either one. The countries eating more fat were also richer, ate more sugar, and lived in other different ways. Keys picked fat.

The bigger problem is what happened next. The American Heart Association put Keys on its committees, the advice went out to the whole country, and once the government printed it in official guidelines it was very hard to walk back. Careers and food companies were built on it. When later trials tried to prove that cutting fat saved lives, most came up empty. The huge Women's Health Initiative put tens of thousands of women on a low-fat diet for years and found no drop in heart attacks. By then the message was too big to question.

Taubes does not claim that fat is a health food or that anyone lied on purpose. His point is simpler. The case was thin from the start, and we treated a guess as settled truth. That should make you slow down before you trust the next big diet rule, and ask what evidence really sits under it. Most of the time the honest answer is less than you would hope.

7 more key ideas in the app

  1. 2. The Diseases of Civilization
  2. 3. The Trouble With Calorie Math
  3. 4. Insulin Runs the Fat Cells
  4. 5. Carbohydrates Pull the Trigger
  5. 6. Sugar Is a Problem of Its Own
  6. 7. Why Eat Less and Move More Backfires
  7. 8. One Root Under Many Diseases
Read the full Dib in the app

Did you know?

  • Taubes came to nutrition from the hard sciences. He studied physics at Harvard and engineering at Stanford, then spent years as a science reporter before turning that eye on diet research and spending about five years on this book.
  • The book grew out of a 2002 New York Times Magazine cover story he wrote called 'What if It's All Been a Big Fat Lie?' He later boiled the same argument down into a shorter, easier read, Why We Get Fat.

Coming soon to the App Store and Google Play

DibsDabs for iPhone and Android is almost ready. Want to know the moment it's out? Send us a note and we'll tell you.

iPhone Coming soon Android Coming soon
Notify me at launch